top of page
  • Writer's pictureBrad Thornton

San Antonio DWI Attorney: What is Retrograde Extrapolation and How Does the State Use it Against You


San Antonio DWI Attorney

Retrograde extrapolation is a concept that plays a crucial role in determining the level of intoxication in Texas for drunk driving offenses. The state of Texas defines intoxication as having a blood alcohol concentration (BAC) of 0.08 or higher. However, if the prosecution chooses to prove intoxication by BAC, they must be able to demonstrate the defendant's level of intoxication at the time of driving, not just at the time of testing.


This is where retrograde extrapolation comes in. It's a scientific method that estimates a person's BAC at the time of driving based on their BAC level at the time of testing and the elapsed time between the two. This information is critical in establishing whether the defendant was indeed intoxicated while operating a vehicle, which is a crucial factor in drunk driving cases.


In this blog post, we will discuss retrograde extrapolation in more detail, including how it works, its potential limitations, and its impact on drunk driving cases in Texas. We will also explore how this concept is used in court and how it may be challenged by a skilled criminal defense attorney. So, let's dive in and learn more about retrograde extrapolation and its role in Texas DWI cases.


How Does the "Science" of Retrograde Extrapolation Work?


Retrograde extrapolation is based on the premise that a person's BAC level increases over time while they are drinking and then decreases over time after they stop drinking. The process of retrograde extrapolation uses mathematical models to estimate a person's BAC level at the time of driving based on the BAC level at the time of testing and the elapsed time between the two.


The primary factor that affects retrograde extrapolation is the rate at which a person's BAC level decreases over time. This rate is influenced by several factors, including the person's body weight, gender, metabolism, and the amount of alcohol consumed. Retrograde extrapolation models take these factors into account to estimate a person's BAC level at the time of driving.


In addition to the mathematical models, retrograde extrapolation also relies on reliable and accurate data regarding the time of drinking, the amount of alcohol consumed, and the time of testing. This data is collected through various methods, such as eyewitness testimony, receipts, and other forms of documentation. When this data is used in conjunction with the mathematical models, it can provide a estimate of a person's BAC level at the time of driving.


Just How Reliable is Retrograde Extrapolation?


Retrograde extrapolation is not a perfect science and there is no foolproof method to determine a person's exact BAC level at a specific point in time. There are several factors that can impact the reliability of retrograde extrapolation, including the accuracy of the data used, the validity of the mathematical models, and the individual differences in the way that each person metabolizes alcohol.


One of the biggest challenges with retrograde extrapolation is that it relies on the assumption that a person's BAC level decreases at a consistent rate over time. However, the rate of decrease can vary widely from person to person and is influenced by several factors, such as body weight, metabolism, and other medical conditions. This variability makes it difficult to accurately estimate a person's BAC level at the time of driving.


In addition, the mathematical models used in retrograde extrapolation are based on estimates of the absorption and elimination rates of alcohol in the body. These rates are not exact and can vary widely from person to person. This means that the accuracy of the retrograde extrapolation depends largely on the validity of the absorption and elimination rates used in the calculation.


Finally, the reliability of retrograde extrapolation also depends on the accuracy of the data used to estimate the BAC level. This includes the time of drinking, the amount of alcohol consumed, and the time of testing. Any errors or inconsistencies in this data can impact the accuracy of the retrograde extrapolation and call its reliability into question.


How Is Retrograde Extrapolation Used in DWI Prosecutions in Texas


In DWI prosecutions in Texas, prosecutors often use retrograde extrapolation as evidence to prove a defendant's level of intoxication at the time of driving. This is usually done through the testimony of a forensic toxicologist in blood test cases or an intoxilyzer supervisor in breath test cases.


Forensic toxicologists and intoxilyzer supervisors are typically the individuals who perform the chemical analysis of the blood or breath sample and provide testimony in court regarding the results. They may have a scientific background and may be considered experts in their field, but they are not necessarily trained in the specific sciences that underlie retrograde extrapolation.


In these cases, the prosecution may offer the testimony of the toxicologist or intoxilyzer supervisor as evidence of the defendant's BAC level at the time of driving. The testimony is based on the retrograde extrapolation calculation that was performed using the BAC level at the time of testing and the elapsed time between the time of testing and the time of driving.


It's important to note that although the testimony of the toxicologist or intoxilyzer supervisor may be considered strong evidence, it is still open to challenge by the defense. The defense may question the accuracy of the data used in the calculation, the validity of the mathematical models, or the reliability of the testimony itself. By doing so, the defense can raise doubt about the prosecution's argument and challenge the accuracy of the retrograde extrapolation estimate.


San Antonio DWI Attorney Brad Thornton


Brad Thornton is a highly experienced San Antonio DWI Attorney who is dedicating his career to defending individuals charged with DWI. With years of experience handling these types of cases, Brad has a deep understanding of the legal and scientific issues involved in DWI prosecutions.


Before entering private practice, Brad served as a chief prosecutor and was a leader on the Vehicular Crimes Team, where he focused on the most severe DWI crashes. In this role, he worked closely with law enforcement agencies and was involved in training officers as part of their DWI programs. This experience gives Brad a unique perspective on the way that DWI cases are prosecuted and allows him to provide effective and knowledgeable representation to his clients.


Brad's extensive experience and commitment to his clients make him an excellent choice for anyone facing DWI charges in the San Antonio area. Whether you are facing a first-time DWI charge or more serious allegations such as Intoxication Assault or Intoxication Manslaughter, Brad has the skills and knowledge necessary to help you achieve the best possible outcome in your case.


If you are facing DWI charges, don't hesitate to reach out to San Antonio DWI Attorney Brad Thornton for a free consultation. He is dedicated to helping his clients understand their rights and options, and will work tirelessly to protect their interests. Contact Brad today at 210-439-5627 to schedule your free consultation and begin the process of defending your rights and freedom.

16 views0 comments

Commentaires


CRIMINAL LAW BLOG

FORMER CHIEF PROSECUTOR

PERSONALIZED ATTENTION TO YOUR CASE

NO HOURLY RATES, ALWAYS A FLAT FEE

CLIENT CENTERED APPROACH TO YOUR CASE

BOARD CERTIFIED IN CRIMINAL LAW 

OVER A DECADE OF EXPERIENCE IN CRIMINAL LAW

WHY HIRE THORNTON CRIMINAL DEFENSE?

Attorney Brad Thornton is a highly experienced and Board-Certified criminal defense lawyer. With his background as a former Chief Prosecutor, he has a unique understanding of the criminal justice system and is able to provide comprehensive and effective representation to his clients. He is also deeply committed to ensuring that all individuals receive fair treatment in court, regardless of their background or circumstances.

Brad Thornton is dedicated to helping his clients achieve the best possible outcome for their case, whether it is in San Antonio or elsewhere in South Texas. He recognizes the stress and anxiety that can come with being accused of a crime, and approaches his clients with compassion while keeping them informed at every step of the process. His knowledge and experience make him a strong advocate for his clients.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn

© 2023 by Thornton Criminal Defense, PLLC. 

Atascosa County Criminal Defense Attorney

San Antonio Office:

111 Soledad, Suite 401

San Antonio, Texas 78205

Tel: 210-439-5627

Atascosa Office:

216 N Bryant St

Pleasanton, Texas 78064

bottom of page